Seven studies compared
| Study | Year | Sample | Language | Method | Finding | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LIU (reported by Science) | 2011 | 34 female college students | US English | Reading and sustained vowels | Fry in over two-thirds, mostly sentence-final | Women only; no male comparison |
| Anderson et al., PLOS ONE | 2014 | 7 women + 7 men speaking; 800 listeners | US English | Listener ratings of imitated fry | Fry judged less hireable, women more harshly | Perception study; fry was performed on request |
| Centenary College (reported by Time) | 2017 | 18–22-year-olds | US English | Not detailed in the report | Men ~25% of speaking time, women ~10% | Media report of unpublished work; 1 source |
| Pillot-Loiseau et al., Anglophonia | 2019 | 9 French women + 9 English speakers (8 women, 1 man) | French & English | Read speech in tandem pairs | English speakers creaked more | 9-pair pilot; not prevalence |
| Uusitalo et al., Journal of Voice | 2022 | 200 samples (95 men, 105 women) | Finnish | 1990s vs 2010s recordings | Women’s creak rose; men not significantly; no age link | One language; abstract-level for us |
| Dutch male speech, Journal of Voice | 2024 | 30 men | Dutch | Spontaneous speech | Creak on about 0–5% of syllables | Men only; abstract-level |
| Brown & Sonderegger; Brown & Clayards (McGill) | 2025–2026 | 49 bilingual speakers (production); 40 listeners (perception) | Canadian English and French | Spontaneous-speech acoustics; separate matched-guise experiment | More creak in men and older speakers; low pitch affected ratings, with no overall face-gender effect | Two peer-reviewed papers; one bilingual sample and one controlled listening experiment |
A 2020 systematic review in PLOS ONE looked at prevalence research across the English-speaking world and found the methods, samples and measurements too different to combine into one number. That is the key to reading this table: the rows are not answering the same question.
Why the hiring and production studies answer different questions
They measured different things. The 2014 PLOS ONE study was about perception: it played performed fry to listeners and asked how hireable the speaker sounded. It never counted how often men or women fry in daily life. The 2025 McGill production study analysed natural recordings from 49 Canadian English–French bilingual public figures. A separate 2026 perception study asked 40 listeners to rate manipulated voices paired with faces. The production finding, more creak in men and older speakers in that sample, addresses a question the hiring study never asked. The perception study found strong voice-quality and moderate pitch effects, no overall face-gender effect, and a small pitch-by-face interaction.
So “women fry more” was never what the 2014 study showed. What it showed was that listeners penalise fry more in women. Those are easy to confuse in a headline.
Male speaker, vocal fry
Female speaker, vocal fry
Speaker 10 (male) and Speaker 2 (female) fry stimuli, Anderson et al. (2014), PLOS ONE, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0.
Language matters
- British English: Science’s 2011 article noted the pattern may run the other way in Britain, with men frying more, but described that as anecdotal.
- Finnish: the 2022 study of 200 samples found women’s creak increased between the 1990s and 2010s (from 1.04 to 1.55 on the study’s scale), while men’s change was not significant, though the share of men with “more” creak rose from 5.9% to 18.1%.
- French: the 2019 pilot found English speakers creaked more than French speakers, and French speakers creaked more in English than in French. French creak is rarely described in the literature.
- Dutch: 30 men creaked on roughly 0–5% of syllables, with large differences between individuals.
For how other languages use creak to carry meaning, see vocal fry around the world.
Age
The 2025 McGill production paper found more creak in older speakers; the 2022 Finnish study found no correlation between age and amount of creak. Both can be true for their samples. Ageing voices do change, but these two studies point in different directions, so we leave the question open.
What we can say with confidence
- Both men and women use vocal fry, in every study that measured both.
- Listeners judge fry more harshly in women, in at least the 2014 study.
- There is no reliable single “percentage of women who fry”; anyone quoting one is quoting one sample.